Topper Copies

The Finance Commission serves as the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism, but despite its efforts to widen the share of states in the divisible pool of taxes, the struggle for financial resources between the center and states has only intensified. Analyse the factors contributing to this paradox and its implications for fiscal federalism in India.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

Finance Commission (FC) (Article 280) is constituted every 5 years by the President of India.

Role of Finance Commission 1. Vertical devolution 2. Horizontal devolution 3. Making recommendations for grants-in-aid. 4. Suggesting other measures for sound finance.

Factors contributing in paradox 1. Less contribution to states in tax. Only 41% of tax collection is devolved to the states as per 15th FC. 2. No contribution to the state in cess. Almost 20% of entire tax collection consists of cess from which no money is granted to the states. 3. As per 15th FC, for horizontal devolution factors like population are considered for giving due share. This proves to be a penalising factor to the states who have taken measures for population control. 4. Centralising nature of Finance Commission. 5. No participation of states in making the appointment of members of Finance Commission & opaque appointment of FC. 6. Freebies are also considered while devolving funds but it granting freebies might be necessary in some states.

Implications for fiscal federalism 1. States and Centre are in confrontation undermining Cooperative federalism. Example: Confrontation in issue of GST Compensation. 2. States performance is low. Example: Huge revenue deficit (fiscal) in various states. 3. Confrontation between the Centre and States regarding finance undermines the overall development process. 4. Huge dependence on grants by States and local bodies is against the idea of federalism and decentralisation hurting the autonomy.

Finance Commission is said to be the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism. It must take measures to empower states for achieving cooperative federalism.