In what ways are Marx's theory of 'Alienation' and Durkheim's theory of 'anomie' different from each other and to what extent can they be seen as having similarities?
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
According to Marx, alienation is the process where workers feel disenchanted, disillusioned and feeling of powerlessness. While anomie, according to Durkheim is a situation of normlessness in the society.
Difference between anomie and alienation
| Anomie | Alienation | |---|---| | It happens when there is rapid social change. Ex- French Revolution | It occurs due to emergence of private property. The level of alienation increases with successive mode of production except in Communism | | It's transitory in nature and disappear when norms and values are reestablished | Feeling of hostility between the workers and the capitalists | | People no longer feel integrated to the society | Only workers feel in capitalist society | | General throughout society ie. felt by all | Workers feel helpless and not aware about their exploitation. ie. class in itself | | People come together to reenact the consensual norms and social order | Capitalist system has to be overthrown and Communism can only reduce alienation | | Solution lies in existing system by reforming it | Exploitative DOL between workers and capitalists | | Can lead to anomic division of labor | |
Similarities between both
| Anomie | Alienation | |---|---| | Creation of social disharmony by lack of common norms and values | Social disharmony and feeling of hostility among the different classes | | Pathological DOL due to anomie ie. Anomic Division of labor where workers don't feel comfort and integrated to the production process | Forced division of labor which is caused by coercion by capitalists. Workers feels disenchanted from self, society, product and production process | | Society looses control over its members. Occupational Associations can play role in reducing anomic DOL in society | Society no longer decides DOL but dominant class of capitalist decides | | The role of Community reduces. There is no single morality in the society. The social solidarity and Collective conscience reduces | The Community no longer controls the material world as was in the primitive society. But the forces of market and Commodities Control the lives of people. Marx calls it "fetishism of Commodities" |
Hence anomie is the transitory situation and stage during the rapid social change. While marx's alienation results out of perverting of the organic linkage between the work and workers. But both are similar in the sense that both create social disharmony but the ways of resolving them are different in the theories of marx and Durkheim