Describe the legal and administrative powers vested in the Election Commission to conduct elections. Assess the effectiveness of the ECI in exercising its powers independently and impartially, and suggest reforms to strengthen its functioning.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Election Commission of India is an independent body under Article 324 Part XVI which has been given the power of superintendence, direction and control of elections of Parliament, State Legislature, President and Vice-President.
Legal and administrative powers 1. To prepare electoral rolls. 2. To determine the model code of conduct for voters, as well as, electors. 3. To register political parties and give the recognition. 4. To determine territorial constituency based on Delimitation Act. 5. To settle disputes arising for the election symbols as per Election Symbol Act. 6. To scrutinize nomination filed by the candidates. 7. To give advise to President and Governor regarding disqualification. 8. To settle disputes related to election petition.
ECI exercising powers independently
Yes - Power to cancel elections in case of booth capturing, rigging. - Chief Election Commissioner and the two Commissioners can be removed in the manner similar to that of judge of Supreme Court. - Security of tenure & conditions of service cannot be altered to their disadvantage. - Use of c-VIGIL app for recording malpractices and flying squads appointed to enforce MCC.
No - Salaries are not charged upon CFI. - Not debarred from reappointment. - No same protection CEC and other election Commissioners. - Cannot deregister a political party. - No legal backing to enforce MCC. - Depends on government for necessary staff.
Reforms to strengthen functioning 1. As per the recommendations of Law Commission, the salaries must be charged upon CFI. 2. As per SC Judgement in Anoop Baranwal Case v/s UoI 2023, PM, leader of opposition and CJI must recommend in appointment. 3. Power to deregister political party must be given. 4. Legal backing to MCC. 5. Use of updated technology in EVM.
ECI is a bulwark of democratic government. Reforms must be taken to uphold the true essence of democracy.