(b) 'Book-view' and 'field-view' of Indian caste system
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Indian caste system has been central to the understanding of Indian society due to its social, economic and political impacts.
Book View
Pioneered by Indological scholar Prof Ghurye, book view based its findings on ancient text, like Vedas, Puranas etc. It provided a culturo-historical perspective for caste and its evolution from 'Purush Sukta'. But this depicted caste as it 'should' be and not how it really is. It failed to understand the dynamism in society and saw caste as a rigid social stratification
Louis Dumont, despite claims of studying text and context, provided largely an ideological perspective on caste. It was based on view of binary between purity and pollution, much as Brahmanism envisaged.
Field View
Based on Microanthropological observations, it was MN Srinivas who found macrosociological generalisation in study of Coorgs of Mysore or Rampura, the dynamism in caste system was unearthed. It was cultural process of Sanskritisation and Westernisation. Sripuram village study by Andre Beteille took Weberian perspective to study interplay of power and class. Along with G.D Berreman's foothill Himalayan study and S.C Dube's Shamirpet study, the village field view was enriched.
Both these perspectives have revealed lot about caste system