"The argument that has long held sway is that child labour, however unfortunate, is inevitable as long as households remained poor". Critically analyse the statement in context of Indian society.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Utsa Patnaik comments about the "Economics of Child labour" and argues that its the single biggest reason why it persists.
In 05-14 yrs age group more than 4cr children work as child labourers. 1. In India, Households with child labourers are concentrated in 5 States(>50%) - Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, UP, Maharashtra and Andhra. 2. Presence in MP, UP, Bihar reflect the fact as Chronic poverty is also found in these states.
[a hand-drawn outline map of India marking child labour hotspots - UP, MP, Bihar, MH, AP, labelled "CHILD LABOUR HOTSPOTS"]
3. Poor households cannot afford sustenance for families by labour of 2 elders alone -> Boys have to contribute specially in Agri farm (>70% child labour is in Agri-rural area) -> Girls also do physical work and take care of younger siblings. 4. Due to poverty, children cannot afford education, books, tiffin etc which leads to drop out. 5. Children from poor households belong to SCs, STs, OBCs, Minority community and may also face discrimination. 6. This leads to child drop out, and out of school children are potential child labourers. 7. Sometimes children are trafficked to Zari, Carpet weaving, or firecracker industry for labour. 8. For bidi rolling, many tribal, rural girls are employed by own families. 9. These instances reflect deeper Inequalities in Indian Society that help perpetuate child labour. 10. In urban slums, children work in hotels, highway dhabas etc and indulge in juvenile delinquency
Hence child labour is the result of a vicious cycle which has poverty at its heart but is sustained by other factors