"Weber's theory of 'The protestant ethic and spirit of capitalism' despite its share of criticism remains bold and illuminating". Critically examine.
Yaksh Chaudhary, AIR 6, 2021
Weber in his book "Protestant Ethic and Spirit of Capitalism" analysed the link between protestantism (ie Calvinism) and Capitalism. He argues that religious ethics of Calvinism led to emergence of spirit of Capitalism as a system of ideas.
Weber started his theory by observing that in different societies, especially developed countries, most of the business leaders, capitalist, high skilled managers belong to Protestant sect. He tried to analyse this link
| Protestant Ethic | Spirit of Capitalism | |---|---| | Concept of calling | Rational pursuit of profit | | Success in this world i.e. asceticism and this worldly religion | Pursuit of profit not because of greed but through an ethical imperative | | Concept of predestination and signs. To uncover these signs, one has to work hard for achieving material success | Hard work and rational organisation of work |
Hence Protestant ethic provided ethical, industrious, sober and dedicated workforce the emergence of Capitalism. Weber further analysed the religions of different countries to prove this theory.
In his book "Religion of India", he says that religious outlook Hinduism and caste system hindered the capitalism emergence in India. Similarly in book, "Religion of China" Weber says that despite having strong market, guild system (ie material conditions), the cultural system (Taoism and Confucianism) discouraged emergence of capitalism in china. On the same lines Gunnar Myrdal in his book Asian Drama suggest that the archaic institutions of India and its culture hindered the development of Indian society. Ideas of weber still guides the researchers and is relevant.
Criticisms of Weber's Theory
1. Veena Das and JPS Uborie suggest that weber analysed Indian society through myopic perspective. Communities of marwadis and Banias, Sikhs etc. encouraged the capitalism. 2. Greschenkron argues that it's not always religion that guides the emergence of capitalism. In Russia, state encouraged the capitalism. 3. Similarly in Japan, family system, led towards push to capitalism. 4. Milton Singer says that caste system doesn't hinder capitalism but can facilitate it.
However weber advocated that spirit of protestantism is one of the factor, other factors of political and material world are also required for capitalism. Hence despite many criticism of weber, his theory can analyse the underdevelopment of African and Asian countries. His theory is still bold and illuminating.