Topper Copies

The transfer of judicial powers to quasi-judicial bodies has raised concerns regarding the creation of a parallel justice delivery system through tribunalization of justice. In this perspective, examine the benefits and drawbacks of empowering quasi-judicial bodies with judicial powers.

Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025

Quasi-judicial bodies are those which either through adjudication or rule making can help in preserving rights to citizens but they are neither legislature nor courts. Example: Tribunals, SEBI, CIC etc.

Benefits of quasi-judicial bodies 1. Relief to courts: These bodies can effectively take up cases of private parties and reduces the number of cases reaching courts which is already overburdened. 2. Speedy trial and justice: Quasi-judicial bodies ensures speedy access to justice (part of right to life). 3. Flexible rules: Flexible rules simplify the adjudication process. 4. Experts opinion: Quasi-judicial bodies contain experts of different domain which ensures effective justice. 5. Protects rights of citizens and check corruption thereby improving the overall development of country.

Drawbacks of quasi-judicial bodies 1. Dependency on government for funds, salaries incorporates executive interference. 2. Tribunals like NGT bypasses high court which undermines judiciary. Example: Ban -> Time and cost overruns in projects because of NGT. 3. Vacancies in quasi-judicial bodies cause inefficiency.

Quasi judicial bodies can prove to be helpful in providing justice if they are made independent of executive and an effective check and balance is maintained in its powers.