In a democratic society, individual rights and freedoms are always balanced against the larger interests of society and the state. To what extent do the constitutional restrictions on fundamental rights strike a balance between individual liberty and societal interests? What factors are considered in evaluating the reasonableness of such restrictions? Refer to the case laws.
Alfred Thomas, AIR 33, 2024
The constitution both recognizes Right to Freedom as a Fundamental Right (Art 19), as well as placing reasonable restrictions on them.
To what extent does this strike a balance between individual liberty and societal interests 1. Every citizen has freedom of speech & expression, but it is reasonably restricted for defamation, contempt of court, maintaining public order etc 2. Every citizen has freedom to move across the country, reside anywhere, settle down etc but it is reasonably restricted on grounds of national security, rights of tribals etc
Thus there is reasonable balance struck between individual liberty & societal interests.
However, the specificities of what is reasonable, and what is not, is often decided on a case by case basis by the judiciary (under Art 13) through judicial review.
Factors considered in evaluating reasonableness of such restrictions "Doctrine of Proportionality" given by Supreme Court in Navtej Johar case, Puttuswamy delineates these factors: 1. Does the executive's or legislature's action lie beyond their powers? (eg) in Minerva Mills case, SC declared amendment (42nd)'s certain provisions which restricted individual rights as violating Basic structure -> declared Art 39b,c over all FRs 2. Is there legitimate state interest involved? 3. Is the restriction arbitrary? (eg.) In Shreya Singhal case, sec 66A of IT Act was deemed too vague and arbitrary 4. Is the restriction disproportionally strong compared to the need? (eg.) In Anuradha Bhasin case, SC declared the internet shutdowns to be too severe
Thus, the judiciary maintains the dynamic balance between individual rights & societal interest.