"Judicial activism is an effective way to promote democratic values and social justice, especially when the other two branches of the government fail to act." Critically examine.
Alfred Thomas, AIR 33, 2024
Judicial activism refers to when the judiciary goes beyond its mandate to pursue some noble goals.
Promotes democratic values 1. Enables fair representation to all classes of citizens (eg) In NALSA case, SC advocated for representation to transgenders 2. Ensures governments are accountable to people (eg.) SC pulling up Centre, Delhi govt. for failure to tackle air pollution 3. Ensures principle of subsidiarity such that power resides with the people (eg.) High courts ruling in favour of Gram Sabhas
Promotes social justice 1. Ensures rights of minorities are preserved (eg.) Navtej Johar case -> LGBTQ+ rights respected/safeguarded 2. Reduces exploitation of the vulnerable (eg.) Bandhua Mukti Morcha case -> labourer rights protected 3. Brings about gender equality (eg.) Sabarimala case -> temple entry for women allowed 4. Works towards upliftment of lower castes (eg.) Reservation upheld for socially/educationally backward classes
Role of judicial activism becomes even more crucial when other two branches of government (Executive and Legislature) fail to act for various reasons: 1. Acting on an issue may be politically infeasible (eg. government not repealing Sec 377 for fear of backlash from orthodox sections) 2. Lack of political will leading to hesitation to act (eg.) Ignoring issues of undertrials until SC stepped in (Hussainara Khatoon case) 3. Lack of expertise in legal matters (eg.) SC clarifying matters under Art 143 after President's request
Judicial activism bridges the gap in situations like these.
However, it has some criticisms as well: - Incentivises elected government to avoid tough decisions and instead pass them on to judiciary - Blurs the line between activism and over-reach - Over-burdens judiciary which already has huge pendency of cases (4.5Cr cases)
What is needed in a healthy democracy is the performance of their roles faithfully by each organ of the government. Thus we must strive to achieve a state where judicial activism is no longer necessary.