Topper Copies

What are the key differences between a federal and a unitary system of government? Can the Indian constitution be considered federal in nature despite its unitary features? Critically examine.

Alfred Thomas, AIR 33, 2024

A system of government can be federal or unitary depending upon the distribution of powers.

| Federal Government | Unitary Government | |---|---| | 1. Power distributed between Centre and State, each independent in their own sphere | 1. Power centralised with lower levels subordinate to higher levels | | 2. Constitution is supreme so as to preserve federal balance | 2. No such necessity (eg. Britain, a unitary state has Parliamentary Supremacy) | | 3. Written constitution so as to clearly demarcate differences and avoid encroachment | 3. No such necessity (Britain, Israel etc have unwritten constitutions) | | 4. Rigid constitution so that central Power may not unilaterally change status quo | 4. Are easily amended | | 5. Independent judiciary so that federal disputes resolved fairly | 5. Integrated judiciary with lower level courts subordinate to higher level courts |

Indian Constitution has a mixture of both federal and unitary features.

Unitary Features

(A) Legislative - Parliament can legislate on State List: a) in national interest (Art 249) b) during Emergency (Art 250) c) if two or more states request (Art 252) d) to fulfill international agreements (Art 253) - Residuary power is with Parliament (Art 248) + In Concurrent List Parliament supercedes (Art 254)

(B) Executive - Union can impose President's Rule (Art 356) - Appointment of Governor by Centre

(C) Judicial - Integrated Judiciary

(D) Financial - Central Finance Commission decides allocation of proceeds of tax - GST has subsumed various state taxes

Inspite of these unitary features, India still can be called Quasi Federal (KC Wheare) because of some federal features: - Separate State Governments - Council of States with representation to all states - Ratification of state legislatures needed to amend federal features of constitution - Division of subjects into Union, State and Concurrent List

India chose to be neither fully federal nor fully unitary - instead choosing a unique blend so as to address its unique challenges.