Enumerate the challenges to cooperative federalism and critically examine the efficacy of various constitutional mechanisms for redressal of federal disputes.
Alfred Thomas, AIR 33, 2024
Cooperative Federalism refers to a federal setup, where there is coordination between Centre and States, and among states, cooperating for the common goal of the larger public interest (eg Team India Wing of NITI Aayog).
Challenges to Cooperative Federalism 1. Power distribution is inherently biased towards centre (eg. Centre can legislate on State List under Art 249, 250, 252, 253 etc) - Asymmetrical Federalism 2. Different political parties in Centre and states tussling (eg. Delhi, Tamil Nadu etc) 3. Competitive federalism over-riding need for cooperation 4. Multiple disputes such as inter-state water disputes (eg Cauvery Dispute), dispute over GST Compensation etc
To address these challenges, various constitutional mechanisms have been institutionalised: 1. Inter State Council - Art 163 2. Tribunals for River Water Disputes - Art 162 3. GST Council (Art 279A)
Examining efficacy of these mechanisms
| Positives | Negatives | |---|---| | Provide platforms for effective coordination and dialogue | ISC not functional | | Most GST Council decisions taken by consensus even if not technically necessary (shows cooperation) | River disputes continue despite final tribunal awards | | | In Mohit Minerals case, SC declared GSTC decisions not binding |
Ultimately what is needed is political will. India must learn from best practices of countries like Australia and Canada who have sustained cooperative federalism by combining existing mechanisms with political will.