Topper Copies

Describe the legislative powers of the governor. Do you think the dual role of governor is justified in a federal country? Give arguments in support of your view.

Alfred Thomas, AIR 33, 2024

While the Governor is the executive head of the state, he also has some legislative powers.

Further, Governor has a dual role under India's constitutional scheme: a) Executive Head of State b) Agent of Centre

Whether it is justified

Arguments in favour: 1. Ensures continuity of governments when state governments fails (eg. taking over administration under Art 356) 2. Helps maintain unity and integrity of India

Arguments against: 1. Undermines democratically elected state govt's mandates (eg NEET Bill not signed by Tamil Nadu Governor) 2. Further increases tussle if biased towards Centre

On a closer look, the role assigned by the constitution is a necessary role given India's specific needs. However there needs to be safeguards to prevent misuse of powers.

Recommendations by Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission (such as committee to select governors) must be implemented.