Explains the role of civil society in promoting democratic values, and its critiques.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Robert Putnam calls civil societies as 'carriers of democracy' highlighting the group's role in bringing socio-political egalitarian ideas for common welfare. It helps in promoting democratic values.
1. Tocqueville notes that civil societies help to mitigate 'tyranny of majority' ex feminist, Dalit, minorities movement. 2. Hegel notes that civil societies acts as a bridge between individual interests and wider interests of the society, ex civil societies role in Narmada Bachao Aandolan, Niyamgiri Hills protest etc. 3. Folks the loopholes of state - Ex Naaz Foundation work for welfare of LGBTQ+, India lawyers' Association in Sabarimala Case - mitigates the unattended areas of democracy. 4. Values of transparency, accountability and legitimacy get advocated (Scholte), ex Association of Democratic Reforms' role in political transparency & RTI. 5. Political participation of citizens increases where civil societies create awareness and trains future leaders (Larry Diamond).
Critique:
1. Shiv Viswanath - Promotes dominant ideologies. 2. John Dry - only safe decisions are taken. 3. Westergaard & Resler - slow effectiveness and no institutional change. 4. Haffernan - failure of civil society can lead to disappointment & disenchantment of citizens.
Hence, as Giddens call them as 'third sector of democracy', civil societies can bring socio-political empowerment in democracy.