Explains the functionalist justification for differential treatment of social groups, and its critiques.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
The functional model and school of thought advocates differential treatment of social groups & individuals to bring social solidarity and value consensus.
Smooth functioning requires division of work and different status:
1. Durkheim through his study of 'division of labour' (DOL) notes that the shift from mechanical to organic DOL is required for social solidarity. 2. Parsons note that individuals/groups are awarded differently based on their levels of alignment with social goals -> improves value consensus. 3. Davie & Moore notes that different roles have different functional importance and hence must be awarded differently, further it acts as a motivation for sacrifice by the scarce talent pool. 4. Warnerc in his 'Reputational Approach' notes that positioning social groups at different levels helps in reducing conflict & promoting appropriate role allocation Ex Jajmani system in Ancient India.
Ex Thercborn & Murdock notes that DOL in family & role allocation helps in reducing conflict and improves harmony.
Racial theory of Herbert Risley does not condemn caste system rather notes its integrative role.
Weberc notes that 'status' acts as a medium of social closure and hierarchy is important in increasing role of bureaucracy.
But the functionalist model has been condemned:
1. David Lockhood - overstresses on solidarity and misinterprets 'interdependence' as integration. 2. Conflict theorists like Marx & Engels note the oppression of bourgeoisie on proletariats. 3. Neomarxists notes, like Gramsci through his idea of 'hegemony' and Althusserc notes that dominant ideologies propagated by repressive & institutional apparatus. 4. Feminists note like Sylvia Walby & Shulasmith Firestone highlight the exploitative nature of patriarchy. 5. MM Tumin criticises the 'reward' approach by noting all roles are equally functional & highlights elite self recruitment.
Functional model further got redefined by the works of Merton & Gunnar Myrdal that brought dynamism.