Topper Copies

Discusses nationalism as both a narrow, parochial ideology and a force for unity and development.

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Stalin defines 'nationalism' as a shared belief among group of individuals sharing common past history, territory, economic landscape culminating into cultural unity.

Nationalism as an ideology is inherently narrow & parochial:

1. Secessionist tendencies are advocated, ex Khalistani movement, Nagalism, as shown in the study of Sanjib Barua. 2. Andrew Pilkington notes the emergence of 'otherisation' in the wake of globalisation which fuels communal hatred among communities. 3. Stuart Hall notes that concept of nationality has led to 'refugee crisis' that develops anti-refugee sentiments due to stronger nationalistic views. 4. Amartya Sen notes that nationalism in India has been emphasised in spreading majoritarian values with religious undertone - threatens minorities & increases disparities. 5. Mannheim notes that emergence of global problems require global approaches (terrorism, climate change) and nationalistic views impedes development.

But Nationalism helps in unity & development:

1. McCrone notes that nationalism is a 'flexible concept' that is the most important ideology of uniting people. 2. Ramachandra Guha notes the changing notions - 'Cricket, Bollywood' form of nationalism. 3. Ernest Gellnere notes that nationalism helps in providing harmony during uncertain times. 4. Paul Hirst - citizens can make someone accountable.

Hence as Benedict Anderson notes its role in uniting an 'imagined community', nationalism is a double edged sword.