Topper Copies

Explains Merton's middle range theory as a bridge between empiricism and grand theory, and its critique.

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Parting ways from classical functionalist perspective and their methodologies, Merton's middle range theories tried to bridge the gap between raw empiricism and generalised grand theory.

Merton notes "Parsons tries to be Newton of sociology while the subject has not got its Kepler" to emphasis the drawbacks of earlier functionalist study in building generalisations (Parson-Action system) without empirical study.

Merton advocates a 'functional paradigm' that is a link between theoretical concepts & empirical data:

1. Creates a trinity of:

2. Focuss on social contexts, meanings and perspectives/boundaries, ex Merton's study of bureaucracy understands its ritualistic role in context of its desired goal of public welfare. 3. Choose concepts which can be operationalised in sociological contexle, ex Merton's study of 'deviance' defines the conflict as a dichotomy of goals and means (operationalisable in nature). 4. Focuses on empirical study - collect data from both primary & secondary sources. 5. Delineate both manifest and latent functions ex Veblen's study of capitalism takes MRT - understands in particular community, manifest -> improves purchasing power, innovation, latent -> consumeristic attitude, greed etc.

Critique:

1. Roberct Bierstedt notes that Merton's MRT suffers from lack of intellectual ambition where high focus is on micro study - leads to fragmentation of sociological research. 2. Raymond Bound - non-novel approach, similar approach taken in typical scientific study. 3. Lack of concrete ideal - extent of generalisation is unclear, value bias can creep in.

Middle Range Theories have been guiding force in studying phenomena like Beteille/Srinivas village studies or Surajit Sinha's study of tribals etc.