Compares Durkheim's and Weber's sociological studies of religion.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
With a synthetic approach dealing with 'macro picture', Durkheim in his 'Elementary Forms of Religion' studies religion's role in producing collective conscience & solidarity, but Weberc undertakes a 'causal-effect' approach & studies it with context of economy & history.
Similarities in Durkheim's & Weber's study of religion:
1. Role in solidarity - Durkheim's study of Arunta tribes and totemism delivers on the role of religion in bringing social solidarity through 'collective effervescence' & 'consciousness'. Weberc also talks about the collective ideologies of material achievement in order to maintain God's grace in Protestant Ethics. 2. Role of Community - Both Durkheim & Weberc understands religion as a part of the community instead of an individual aspect of living, unlike Peter Bergers's phenomenological approach. 3. Neglects conflict - Both sociologists propose a 'functional model' of religion that overlooks the dysfunctions and conflict associated with the religion. 4. Neglects contemporary religion - studied religion from primitive or historical context and did not delve into contemporary role of religion - Civic Religion, Clergy's role etc.
Differences between both approaches:
1. Aspect of study - Durkheim studies 'totemism' as elementary form of religion but Weber undelines role of religion in context of wider capitalism and takes an explanatory stance with causal-effect phenomenon. 2. Role of Rites & sacrifices - Durkheim's study deals with sacred-profane and various rites (commemorative, sacrificial etc.) but Weber is more focused in the inherent values of religion. 3. Scope of study - Weberc takes a broader scope - studied Protestant Ethics & Hinduism, Confucianism, Buddhism & conducted comparative study but Durkheim tends to generalise by study of one totemic religion. 4. Agents of social change - Weberc's study highlights religion's role in social change, but Durkheim is status quoist & advocates religion promotes harmony.
Critique:
- Marx - Religion as opium of masses. - Dorothy Smith - feminist model - both ignores the exploitative role of religion. - Luckman - phenomenological - Religion is individualistic.
Hence, Durkheim & Weber further enhanced & inspired other models of religion in contemporary sociology.