Explains Marx's use of historical materialism to understand modern capitalism, and where his ideas fall short.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Marx takes a conflict perspective and highlights the control of bourgeoisie over modes of production leading to alienation & exploitation of proletariats.
Marx study of historical materialism explain the dynamics of modern capitalism:
1. Growing Inequality - 1% of top Indians having 45% of wealth (Oxfam Report) highlights the concepts of pauperisation & proletarianization of Marx. 2. Consumerism - Marx's idea of 'Commodity Fetishism' highlights the growing materialistic attitudes of capitalism, ex iPhone, branded clothes. 3. Economic determinism - Economy forms the infrastructure, ex role of money & status in marriage alliances, religion becoming consumerist etc. 4. 'Historical' materialism - Utsa Patnaik studies the shift from feudal to capitalistic mode in rural India and notes 'partial capitalism' noting prevalence of 'historical materialism'. 5. Alienation - Ancwar & Graham note the alienation among gig economy worker and terrible working conditions.
But Marx's ideas fails to understand various facets:
1. Rise of Middle Class - Frank Parkins note the rise as against proletarisation of Marx. 2. Incomplete capitalism - AR Desai notes that capitalism in India is not as a response to breakdown of feudal agency. 3. Decomposition of labour/capital - Ralph Dahrendorf where workers are becoming skilled, semiskilled & unskilled -> against homogenisation. 4. Neomarxism - Gramsci notes about 'counter hegemony' of proletariats & disapproves revolution.
Hence, Marx is the pioneer in understanding inherent conflicts in understanding capitalism.