Topper Copies

Critically analyze the concept of the creamy layer among SC/STs in the context of reservation policy. Does this move advance or undermine the goal of social justice?

Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025

The concept of creamy layer in SC/ST reservation posits income and asset thresholds for inclusion in reservation-based quotas.

As per the Supreme Court in Davinder Singh's Case, it seeks to further substantive equality by ensuring that benefits reach the most disadvantaged first.

Creamy layer as advancing social justice 1. SC/ST were legal categories imposed on or internal jati hierarchy, within lower castes (Srinivas) or on differently placed tribes (Desai). 2. Hence, these are not uniform social categories, but rather have internal socio-economic gradation. 3. Access to similar opportunities leads to the creation of an elite, cornering the benefits of affirmative action.

Thus (Gopal Guru) documents the emergence of Dalit middle class out of benefits of affirmative action in education and public employment. (Virginius Xaxa) has similarly documented the emergence of a tribal elite that has disproportionate benefits, whereas PVTGs have been left behind on most developmental indicators (Dhebar Commission).

4. The Supreme Court thus in Indra Sawhney's Case argued that creamy layer allows us to address this internal disparity.

Limitations of the concept of creamy layer 1. Discrimination faced by SCs/STs is not just economic, rather it is social as well. (Louis Dumont) argued that the logic of purity/pollution applies irrespective of position in secular hierarchy. 2. Even affluent Dalits or STs may face institutional discrimination: (Gopal Guru) has highlighted internalized casteism in higher education. Similarly, North Eastern tribes face everyday racism, impeding support and integration. 3. Intersectional Reading: Kimberly Crenshaw argues that disadvantage is cummulative - hence, while economic disadvantage may be removed, there may be social, or region-based disadvantage. 4. Ignores difference between affluent SC/ST and the "general category": Desai & Dubey using IHDS data showed - - persistent educational deficit - employment discrimination - reduced mobility even equalizing the economic position of individuals.

Hence, (Anup Surendranath) has argued that an intersectional reading supports a sub-categorization based approach that allows for - - prioritizing the most marginalized among SCs, STs - ensuring female SC/ST representation - acknowledging differences from mainstream, upper caste society

Towards this, (Tarunabh Khaitan) advocates a shift from group based to individual centric affirmative action that looks at a 11-point social deprivation index to further social justice.