How does Indian morality differ from constitutional morality, and what does this mean for social change (20 marks)
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Constitutional morality is based on ethos of equality, liberty and fraternity, which departs from the 'Indian morality' that has structural inconsistencies & schisms.
Indian morality is different from constitutional morality →
1. Role of Tradition - Baviskar notes that Indian democracy is not based on merit but traditional values of caste & creed guide the system. 2. Structural Inconsistencies - KL Sharma notes various dichotomy like secularism without religious tolerance, rule of law without caste harmony, bureaucracy without innovation 3. Prismatic Modernity - Dipankar Gupta in his 'Mistaken Modernity' notes that true modernity is not about economic growth but individual dignity & liberty (constitutional morality), but Indian structure with incidents of Hathras rape, mob lynchings highlight the defect of constitutional ethos. 4. Role of Religion - Although constitution prescribes secularism, TN Madan notes that religion is inherent in Indian value system and attempts to uproot it will lead to religious fundamentalism. 5. Culture - Constitution prescribes gender equality & liberty but as Uma Chakravorty & Veena Mazumdar note, women are bound by values of 'Pativrata' & Leela Dubey notes how she is told to fulfill 'Pitrarin' only by giving birth to male child. 6. Fraternity - Sanjib Barua notes the relative deprivation among North-East Tribes that lead to their assertiveness against constitutional morality of fraternity.
It affects social change as envisioned —
(a) Communalism - Ashis Nandy notes the role of religion in political conflicts. (b) Traditions have led to cultural enslavement of women, as Malvika Karlekar notes, inspite of education, women are oppressed. (c) Caste is a hindrance to social mobility, as Deshpande notes the Indian morality of caste & hierarchy has been intensified in PRIs, cooperatives & land reforms. (d) Xaxa notes that tribals continue to be exploited because of state policies and leads to secessionist policies. (e) Ghanshyam Shah notes that poverty continues to be pervasive due to failure of state policies.
As Beteille notes, it is not 'laws' that guide the true direction of social change, but 'culture' does.