Does education help or hinder social mobility in India (10 marks)
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Radhakrishnan notes that education is the most important force of social mobility in India, but the lived reality paints a complex picture as against desired.
Education helping in social mobility
→ Bhattacharya notes that education helps in questioning traditional, exclusionary dogmas & helps in mobility. → Kamat highlights that education has helped in intergenerational mobility and expanded the job opportunities. → Beteille's study of Sripuram highlights that education of Adi Dravidians have helped in social empowerment of marginalised. → Social reformers like Ambedkar who was a product of modern education, Savitri Phule used education as a tool for social mobility.
But education can be hindrance to social mobility →
1. AR Desai questions the effectiveness of education because the conditions of SCs & STs continue to deplete. 2. Malvika Karlekar notes that inspite of education, women continue to be oppressed & their position does not necessarily improve. 3. Xaxa notes that lack of tribal education, education in local language, education does not help in emancipation of tribal populace, rather unemployed youth indulged in drugs. 4. Jan Dreze notes that caste system acts an impediment, ex caste violences in Rohit Vemula Case etc. 5. Hambi Sen & Jairam note the difference in private & government schools & in urban-rural education leading to increased disparity.
Hence as Gandhiji notes, education should not just be about literacy, but true emancipation of individuals.