How do contemporary forms of marriage challenge traditional social norms in India, and with what social implications (20 marks)
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Marriage with function of Dharma, Praja and Rati is guided by social, cultural and religious norms which have witnessed metamorphosis in their structure & function.
Contemporary forms of marriage challenge traditional social norms —
1. Impact on women - Blumberg & Dawki notes that women have higher flexibility in choosing partners noting gender empowerment against the cultural values of past. 2. Uma Chakravorty notes that Brahmanical culture puts more pressure on 'Pativrata' image of women, but DL Sheth notes secularisation and deritualisation in Indian marriages. 3. Inter caste marriages - Urbanisation and modernity influences marital alliances and caste endogamy is on decline. 4. MS Gore notes that consanguinal bonds are weakened with rising conjugal bonds leading to nuclear households. 5. Jeffrey Weeks note the rise of live-in relationships and MoSPI report notes that Indian youth delay in marriage, with decline in 'virgin marriages'. 6. Roseneil notes the rise of gay alliances and as can be seen in Indian societies after decriminalisation of homosexuality. 7. Solagamy as new form of marriage (Gujarat) has been witnessed noting the deviance from traditional social norm.
Social Implications & Conflicts →
1. Shobhada Maitra (TISS) notes that although men in India wants women to work but want them to tradition bound, this conflict rise to conflict. 2. Hart & Leach notes that divorces are on rise due to growing & changing demands of marriage. 3. Rapoport notes the rise of 'single household' and Brannen notes 'beanpole families' where intergenerational alliances are high but intragenerational alliances are low. 4. Neolocal household - with dual career families on rise, Srinivas notes that Indian families are adjusting as per needs of globalisation. 5. Women Empowerment/Crisis → women have more flexibility in marriage (Benston) but also there is rise in vulnerability due to divorce (Amitabh Kundu)
Hence, marriages in India restore tradition but challenge the same in the face of modernity.