Topper Copies

How is the mode of production in Indian agriculture characterised by different scholars (20 marks)

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

AR Desai notes a shift in mode of production in Indian agrarian structure due to British mercantilism and colonial exploitation with Zamindari System & commercialisation of agriculture.

But Dhanagre notes that mode of production is varied in Indian context and cannot be universalised —

a. PC Joshi notes the prevalance of feudal structure because 80% of areas have not witnessed land reforms, but there are modifications in tenancy reforms.

b. Utsa Patnaik notes the classification in terms of Kulak, Strednik & Bednik, but notes that various factors like land use, profitability, labour inputs etc determine mode of production.

c. Kathleen Gough provides a four fold classification and notes 'partial capitalism' as most of the (1) production is for family and (2) all profits are not reinvested for capitalist growth.

d. Gail Omvedt notes various locations experience mode of production differently, ex - (i) pure capitalist (ii) semi capitalist (iii) semifeudal and (iv) feudal depending on land economy.

[a branching diagram connecting circled numerals i-iv]

e. But Jan Breman notes a capitalist shift in Indian agrarian structure as he notes a shift in patronage to exploitation in study of South Gujarat as labourers are alienated from land produce marking capitalist mode of production.

f. Vibha Arora in her 'Globalisation & depeasantisation', notes that MNCs exploit the farmers leading to depeasantisation and marginalisation of farmers, taking a fresh take on changing mode of production.

g. Rudolph & Rudolph in 'In Pursuit of Lakshmi' term the 'bullock capitalists' who lack capital but with land consolidation have emerged as a powerful social group in agrarian economy.

With varied mode of production, agrarian distress is one common attribute among all, so Gurpreet Mahajan advises improvement in industry as an antidote to agrarian crisis.