Topper Copies

Is caste a major barrier to social mobility, and why do caste-based inequalities persist (20 marks)

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Ambedkar notes that "caste system is not a brick wall or barbed wire that prevents social interaction of Dalits, but it is a social and psychological notion that hinders the growth of Dalits".

Caste system as a major barrier to social mobility →

1. Urban mobility - Srinivas notes that Brahmins had upper edge with social capital in furthering goals with opportunities of urbanisation. 2. Arijit Pathak notes the impediments due to caste system in attaining higher education, due to discrimination, ex separate rows for Dalits in midday meal schemes, Rohit Vemula case. 3. Green Revolution and land reforms strengthened the caste relations (Deshpande) that acts as a barrier for social mobility. 4. Self recruitment - Subramaniam & Tapda notes that employment is achieved mostly by kinship, caste and nativity, with Brahmins having disproportionate advantage. 5. Poverty - Ghanshyam Shah notes the massive poverty among Dalits, example Thorat notes 75% of Dalits are landless. 6. Lack of representation - Gail Omvedt notes that BSP lacked clear ideology and there is a political vacuum in emancipation of Dalits. 7. Social disabilities - Prasad notes 150 types of disabilities and untouchability & prevalance of caste endogamy act as hindrance to social mobility. 8. Dalit elites - Hengde notes most of the reservation benefitted a small elite Dalite

Factors that contribute to persistence of caste-based inequalities

1. Political organisations - Gail Omvedt notes that inspite of 73rd & 74th Constitutional Amendment, Dalits lack true power in Panchayati Raj Institutions 2. Socio-cultural norms - Surinder Jodhka notes that even though Dalit movements take a world-view, cultural norms are divisive 3. Caste endogamy - Iravati Karve stressed its importance in emancipation of Dalits 4. Neotraditionalism - Yogendra Singh notes that transport, communication system & present social media also reinforces caste inequalities 5. Education - Jean Dreze notes that cultural reproduction is affirmed by current education system.

As Beteille notes that future of India is not at caste in stone, but forces of modernity will lead to reduction of caste inequalities,