How can Ghurye's Indological approach be used to study cultural revivalism in contemporary India (20 marks)
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
As the father of Indian sociology, GS Ghurye pioneered the Indological approach that relied on archaeological evidences, manuscripts and ancient texts to understand Indian society.
In the wake of globalisation and modernisation, cultural revivalism is evident and can be studied from Ghurye's lens —
i. Ghurye on caste - Ghurye took a Hinduised approach in understanding the origin and attributions of caste. He notes the characteristics as (i) segmental division (ii) hierarchy (iii) religious/civil disabilities (iv) caste endogamy (v) occupational segregation (vi) heredity as can be seen in current times, ex caste endogamy is rampantly practised, Thorat notes 75% Dalits are landless
ii. Study on Tribes - calling them as 'Backward Hindus', he classified tribes as 'Hinduised tribes', 'Partially Hinduised tribe' and 'Hill Section'. The similar integrational approach can be seen in Sahay's study of Oraon tribes and Sinha's caste-tribe continuum.
iii. Study on Religion - With works like 'Indian Sadhu' and 'God & Men', Ghurye studied the role of Sadhus in maintaining mysticism in society and considered religion to be dynamic and at centre of cultural heritage. Ex India witnesses religious revivalism, ex Hijab Case, rise of sects and cults like Radhaswami Movement etc.
iv. Study on Urbanisation - With an optimistic view, Ghurye considers urban areas as 'cradle of innovation', similarly present day urban areas are the flagpost of entrepreneurial growth and economy (Mehta)
v. On culture - Ghurye's study considers culture at the epicentre and his study understands rituals like 'Pitra-Shradh', caste endogamy etc. as maintenance of cultural heritage, Leela Dubey notes the practice of such tradition prevalent in modern families as well.
Kosambi - tribals were forced to integrate to Aryan culture due to exploitation
Critique → - Carol Upadhyay - lack of economic aspects in study - TK Oommen - over Hinduised view - FG Bailey - caste is divisive and non-integrational
Inspite criticism, Ghurye established sociology as a distinct discipline and his work inspires modern Indology of Romila Thapar & Devdutt Pattnaik.