What are the definitional issues that obstruct tribal development in India (10 marks)
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
DN Majumdar defines "tribes to be social groups with territorial affinity with no specialisation, have distinct language & culture, and tendency to maintain social distance from other tribes & castes".
Definitional issues are an obstacle in tribal development —
1. No objective criteria for STs - Ex Dublas in plains in Gujarat have been termed as ST, but Maoris in Chitrakoot Forests are not backward enough to gain ST status. 2. Degree of assimilation - SC Dubey's 5 fold classification and Ghurye's 'Hinduised tribe' conception highlight different degree of assimilation, ex Sentinelese are distant but Gujjars & Bauris have been mainstreamed. 3. Cultural change - Sahay notes conversion of religion of Sarna to Christianity among Oraons community, but various NE tribals maintain totemism & Naturism. 4. Retribalisation - DN Majumdar notes the rise of retribalisation among various caste groups leading to confusion and implementation of tribal schemes. 5. Occupational basis - Kosambi notes that tribals who have started ploughing have been perceived as non-tribals leading to issues of social welfare, ex Negis have appreciable representation in civil services.
Inspite of definitional issues, tribes have primitive way of living and need specialised attention as envisioned in Nehru's Panchsheel.
So Xaxa notes that tribal welfare should not remain as 'constitutional prescription but lived reality'.