What are the features of the evolutionary approach to social change, illustrated through the major evolutionary and cyclical theorists (part a of an optional question).
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
The classical sociology in early days was influenced by various intellectual antecedents like philosophy of history and biological theory of evolution that promoted a universal evolutionary theory of social change.
Sociologists who claim that society moves in a linear fashion advocate an 'evolutionary approach' with characteristics of
Durkheim in his study of social change marks the change in mechanical solidarity to organic solidarity where society moves towards a more civilised/scientific form due to growing specialisation.
- Morgan studied the evolution of society marked by material development that traversed from savagery -> barbarism -> civilisation. - August Comte with an 'ideational approach' emphasised on the change in modern ideas that evolutionise society from theological -> metaphysical -> positivist society marked by development. - Spencer with an naturalist perspective aligns his thought with Darwin's theory and advocated for 'social evolution' - Neo-functionalists like Parsons advocate that 'differentiation' and 'integration' makes the society evolve with increasing capacity of adaptation
He notes the evolution to modernity —
1. Primitive (tribes of Australia) 2. Archaic (Egypt and Mesopotamia) 3. Historical (India and China) 4. Seed-bed (Israel, UAE) 5. Modern (USA, UK)
- Leslie White focussed on evolution of society with increase in use of energy - Convergence Theorists like Kunlop advocate that societies eventually converge to modernity and scientific achievements
Cyclical theory: Spengler notes society from birth-growth-decay-death
Smelser focusses on structured strain, criticised by Samir Amin who refutes the same citing example of Latin America. Conflict theorists (V. Allen) attributes relative deprivation for social change.
Hence, even though the linear growth of society holds true, gross generalisation can be faulty and inadequate