What was the role of positivist methodology in attaining value neutrality in sociology, and what are its limitations (part e of the second compulsory question).
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Positivist methodology formed the pioneer school of sociological discipline propounded by early sociologists like Durkheim and Comte in an attempt to establish it as a distinct discipline of science.
Role of Positivist methodology to attain value neutrality ->
1. Promoted objectivity: focused on data and facts that adopts the methods of natural science, positivist methodology studied social facts as observable and quantifiable entities. 2. Free from biases of researcher: Researcher's beliefs and prejudices were kept at bay as the methodology utilised scientific analysis (multivariate, concomitant statistical analysis) to theorise concepts. 3. Increase external validity: By reliable method of data collection (life experiments, structured interviews, surveys), the experiments yield similar results leading to generalisations. Ex Durkheim study of suicide.
But the method has limitation
1. Weber notes that human do not just behave but they act, emphasising on the inner meaning and value judgements 2. Gunnar Myrdal notes that 'total objectivity is a myth' and emphasised on values' importance 3. Symbolic interactionists like Blumer highlights the importance of symbols making meaning 4. Phenomenologists argue that causal-effect study lacks validity and should not be goal.
From Comte to Durkheim to Columbia school of sociology advocating multivariate analysis, positivism has led the way in establishing unique character of sociology