Is education a means of social change or a mechanism for maintaining status quo (part c of an optional question).
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
On the words of Radhakrishnan, 'education is the main agent of social change' that is even powerful than traditional institutions, but education's role in actually yielding changes is equally debated in sociological milieu.
Education has means of social change ->
1. Karmat notes education has been helpful in self-discovery and social reforms along with paving the path for nationalism in colonial world. 2. Bhattacharya emphasise education as agent for social mobility, ex growth of IITs/NITs led to creation of widened upper middle class -> social mobility. 3. Parsons note that education helps in effective role allocation where it helps in transitioning from traditional particularistic society to 'universalistic society'
But education is also instrumental in maintaing status quo ->
1. Althusser notes education as an 'ideological apparatus' in furthering dominant ideology preventing social change. 2. Bourdieu notes that education leads to 'cultural reproduction' of similar values across generations. 3. Karuna Ahmed notes that education might bring ideational change but structural changes cannot be brought. 4. A R Desai laments the failure of education in empowerment rather it widened inequality 5. Tawney's 'tadpole theory' notes only 'elite among bottom' gets benefitted (elite Dalit/tribe)
Hence, as Tomlinson notes, education should be liberating, harmonising and democratising for true empowerment.