Topper Copies

What is the relative utility of quantitative and qualitative methodology in sociological research (part b of an optional question).

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

While the positivist school of sociology advocated for use of quantitative methodologies to attain objectivity in research, the latter schools focussing on 'microsociology' emphasised on qualitative methodology.

Hammersley notes that quantitative methodology helps to understand/identify the patterns but qualitative ones reveal the reason behind them.

Utility of quantitative research :-

1. Ackroyd and Hughes provide the utility of social surveys in three domains: i) factual (census statistics) ii) Attitudinal (UK's survey on atheism) iii) explanatory (Marshall's study of capitalism and white collar jobs). 2. Making generalisations: Durkheim's study on 'suicide' using multivariate analysis and concomitant analysis help in establishing generalisation -> [suicide inversely proportional to solidarity] 3. Improving reliability: focussed on data and hence yield similar results on multiple experiments, Ex Howell and Frost lab experiments to understand the different types of leadership 4. Establish causal relationship: in building hypothesis and testing the same to prove/nullify the same.

But qualitative methodologies reveal the inner meanings ->

1. Ethnomethodological methodologies like Participant observation helps to understand the intent and meanings of social acts, ex Sudhir Venkatesh study on drug leaders and Teela Sanders study on sex workers. 2. Critical methodologies goes one step ahead in advocating for social change. Ex Paul Willis study of working class lads. 3. More ecological validity: Wilkinson notes that focus groups imitates symbolic interactionism, produce more valid data. 4. Weber's methodologies like Verstehen and Ideal types have been essential to make the discipline value neutral.

Hence, as Ray Pawson notes the debate of methods as 60's hangover, both complement each other to further the paradigm of sociology.