Why is defining 'tribe' a persistent problem in Indian sociology? How do these definitional dilemmas affect state policy?
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
(A.R. Desai) points out that tribes in India lie on a spectrum of differential integration in Indian society, making common anthropological features difficult to find.
Fig: Degrees of integration
Definitional Problems 1. Lack of scholarly consensus: While D.N. Dhangare characterized tribes by their relative isolation, G.S. Ghurye argues that tribes are "backward Hindus" with imperfect integration into Indian society 2. Colonial legacy: classification of tribes as "criminal", barbarians, primitive -> ethnocentric bias promoting white man's burden (Nicholas Dirk). This continued to influence definitions that stressed "primitive institutions" etc. 3. Tribe-caste Continuum (F.G. Bailey) argued that societies are often not fully tribal-segmental-egalitarian or caste-organic-hierarchical but lie somewhere between the two 4. Andre Beteille pointed out the following diversions from the ideal type:
| Ideal type | Counter-example | | --- | --- | | Geographically isolated and tied to their land (Dhangare) | Tribes like Meenas are quite integrated and spread over large parts of India | | Distinct language, culture, dresses | S.C. Dube has highlighted the parochialization of mainstream culture to tribal society and universalization of tribal customs. Increasing adoption of Hindi & vernacular languages -> endangered tribal languages | | Egalitarian tribal society (Dube) | Presence of class within tribe, and a tribal elite undermines this ideal type (Dube) |
Impact on State policy 1. Improper classification (Verrier Elwin) suggested a differential approach -> isolation for isolated tribes, socio-economic development for integrated/assimilated tribes. Such differentiation not maintained, leading to improper assimilation 2. Cornering of benefits by tribal elite, leading to a tribal middle class and otherization of marginal tribal voices (Xaxa). 3. Inadequately tailored policies -> not respecting distinct social & cultural institutions. eg> Xaxa committee pointed out inadequate devolution to Gram Sabhas etc. 4. Inadequate protection for marginalized tribes led to feelings of relative deprivation, especially in Central and Eastern India, leading to left wing extremism (Nandini Sundar).
Hence, (Surajit Sinha) recommends a calibrated governance approach recognizing the tribe-caste continuum.