Discuss the intersection of patriarchy and entitlements in shaping women's roles and rights within Indian kinship systems.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
India has a diversity of kinship systems which show differential approach to women's position, role and entitlements in forms like patriliny, matriliny etc.
North Indian Kinship System 1. Characteristics: Patrilineal, patriarchal, patrivirilocal, joint family marked by coparcenary land ownership (M.S. Gore) 2. Status of women -> Subordinated to men -> Seen as the "seed" -> passive, nurturing principle that does not contribute to inheritance & lineage of the child (Leela Dube) - Pervading gender notions of self-sacrifice enshrined in concepts like "Pativrata", "Sati Savitri" and "Ardhangirni" (Leela Dube) 3. Entitlements Patriarchy contributes to diminishing entitlements (i) For the girl child - limited access to health and education opportunities -> capability deprivation (Sen & Nussbaum) (ii) Socialization -> low self esteem and "putting up" with injustices (Kamla Bhasin) (iii) Nutritional deprivation owing to "bread-winner" role of men (John Houdinott) -> bad health outcomes such as high anaemia in NFHS-5. (iv) Limited autonomy - traditionally, little choice in spouse, career etc. (v) Burdened with upholding "purity of the lineage & caste" -> policing women's bodies under Brahmanical Patriarchy (Uma Chakravarty). (vi) Economic Dependency - fostered by limited access to property rights, curtailing economic freedom (Bina Agarwal)
South Indian Kinship System Characteristics (Iravati Karve) -> can be matrilineal & patrilineal -> matriarchal & patriarchal -> marriage preference rules: uncle-niece and cross-cousin marriages (Dumont)
Status of women -> Higher autonomy -> No asymmetric relations of bride & bridegroom's family due to marriage in close relation -> Traditional Nayar Tarawad - choice of spouse, matriliny, matrilocality
Entitlements 1. Better position of women owing to kinship and better education -> better socio-economic indicators like near-100% literacy. 2. Despite some rights in property, limited decision-making power since decisions taken by brother/husband.
Western Kinship System 1. Characteristics: mostly patriarchal, patrilineal and patrilocal. 2. Status: better than in the Northern kinship system. 3. Entitlements -> Limited property rights -> more access to stridhan -> Customs emphasizing bond of bride with her family
Eastern Kinship System 1. Characteristics: matrilineal & matriarchal tribes (North East) - Khasis, also patriliny etc. 2. Status: greater autonomy 3. Entitlements: Khasis -> matriliny where property passes to youngest daughter but decision still by males
Hence, there is a tremendous regional variation in status and entitlements of women.