Topper Copies

Critically evaluate dependency theory in explaining persistent under-development.

Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025

Dependency theory was first formulated by Latin American theorists to explain patterns of underdevelopment and exploitation in the third world.

A.G. Frank, in "Development of Underdevelopment", has argued that -

1. Underdevelopment of the third world is not due to internal characteristics, but external exploitation. 2. Underdevelopment in Latin America, Asia, Africa comes from economic exploitation by first world countries.

*Metropolitan - periphery model*

Similarly, Wallerstein proposed the following World Systems Model:

Critical Scrutiny - Does not explain benefits of integration of capitalist production, eg the East Asian Tigers - Amartya Sen argues that aid and transfers have led to better health and education outcomes - Imprecise solutions like protectionism, which do not reduce poverty, eg North Korea - With decline of communism, and "end of history", absence of alternative development paradigm (Fukuyama)

However, the theory has enduring significance in explaining neo colonialism, data colonialism and uneven opening of economies through WTO.