Topper Copies

8. (b) "The pluralist and multi-religious character of the Indian society is facing constant challenges". Discuss the statement in context of the problems of religious minorities in India.

Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018

India is a land of multiculturalism, with a diversity of religion, language and regions. The doctrine of 'Sarva Dharma Sambhav' is rooted in our ethos and manifestly stated in the Constitution.

But this character faces constant challenges: - Communal forces try to exploit sectarian differences in social tradition for political mobilisation. - Interests of different communities are juxtaposed against each other. - Cultural practices and beliefs are suppressed or ignored due to insensitivity. - The Justice Sacchar committee highlighted the plight of Muslims and their inadequate representation in education, police, service jobs etc, and general poverty. - Discrimination is widespread in employment: as 86% of the workforce is in the informal sector, Jan Breman posits that there, caste and faith act as signposts for work, leading to weak networks and opportunities. - Many lower castes who converted to Christianity are not granted SC status like Sikh or Buddhist converts, which relegates them to marginalisation there also. - Support for minorities by the state is seen by the majority as a sign of ignorance by a state that is trying to politically consolidate against them. - Rajiv Bhargava argues that the majority sees its own cultural values at the core and relegates minority values to the periphery, but rather they are two sides of the same coin.

[diagram: a circle for 'Majority' containing 'Minority', transforming via an arrow into two separate, equal circles for 'Majority' and 'Minority', captioned 'Two sides of same coin']

- This causes suppression of values and cultural traditions. - Lack of education opportunities perpetuates occupational segregation. - General intolerance causes political voices to go unheard, and disgruntled people may even cause communal conflict.

Hence, the multicultural, tolerant character must be maintained, both for pragmatic coexistence and as an ideology fundamental to Indian secularism.