Topper Copies

6. (a) Critically analyse, to what extent contemporary Indian society is dominated by the nuclear family structure.

Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018

The apparent structural changes, like industrialisation, urbanisation and globalisation, have deeply impacted family-kin relations in India. - The spread of nuclear families, by disintegration of traditional joint families, is observed. - IP Desai, in a study of Mahuwa, found nuclearised families were dominating. - The Allen Ross Bangalore study remarks that the nuclear family has become the typical family type. - MS Gore, in his study, asserts that 2/3 of families were nuclear, while 1/3 had been joint. - Dual-career families make it necessary that children have to migrate to cities and leave paternals behind. - This pushes neolocal family formation and migration; also, the nuclear family, as a tendency of individualism/privacy, dominates (symmetrical families).

But studies have also focussed on how the "joint" family is perceived, and contradicting evidence occurs: - KM Kapadia, in a Gujarat study, finds that joint families are still more in number. - Sacchidananda, in the Bihar Shahbad study, confirms the prominence of joint families. - Earlier, M N Srinivas, in a study of Okhla industries, and Milton Singer, for Madras industries, found that the joint family was not only prevalent but also suitable for families. - Patricia Uberoi explains stem families, where one of the parents stays with the family in the urban area for child care and support. - MSA Rao argues that the Breakdown Hypothesis is a largely Western concept, and India has rather followed traditional families and urbanism.

Analysis based on the household, by AM Shah, sees this as a development cycle, and exhorts that jointness be seen in orientation. Though family in India might get structurally nuclear, it is still functionally joint.