3. (b) "Customary agrarian relations are undergoing dynamic changes". Analyse.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
The change in the mode of production in agriculture, as well as the forces of modernisation and globalisation, are impacting customary agrarian relations.
- The breakdown of the Jajmani system with the coming of the market economy led to disruption in traditional exchanges. - Jan Breman sees that this has moved patronage to exploitation: rich landlords now hire migrant labour, extract maximum work and pay very low wages. - The pauperisation of tenants due to their forceful eviction has led to concealed tenancy. - Due to land reforms, many families divided lands among brothers to escape ceiling laws. According to Lakshminarayan, this has led to real divisions in traditional joint families. - SS Nehru remarks that indebtedness is sprawling, and mostly lower-caste households are indebted, pushing farmer suicides. - According to SS Jodhka, these farmers take loans for agricultural (peasant) inputs and fall into a debt trap, pushing the entire family into debt bondage of rich moneylenders/landowners.
Due to the coming of the modern banking system and state welfare policies, some positive changes are also seen: - Due to rural banks and cooperative societies, access to credit is penetrating, reducing dependence on informal sources and exploitation, to 40% from 90% at independence. - Migration opportunities to urban areas in industries has provided freedom to lower castes to explore employment and get skilled. - But due to male migration, 60% of agri-labourers today are women, and feminisation of poverty is seen. - Contract farming with MNCs and global value chains opens up forward linkages for selling in the market.
Dynamism in agrarian relations has been apparent, and its impact has been felt differentially across caste and class.