3. (a) Discuss the Louis Dumont's concept of purity and pollution. Comment on the suitability of applying these concept to the study of Indian society.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Louis Dumont's perspective opens up a door for an analysis of Indian society based on both text (indological, Ghurye-inspired) and context (based on real practices).
Borrowing the 'binary' concept from Levi Strauss, Dumont seeks to juxtapose Western society with the Indian one.
Inspired by Bougle's emphasis on cultural factors, Dumont argues that the caste system must be viewed in an ideological perspective, as a binary between purity and pollution. This has been outlined in "Homo Hierarchicus."
He posits that the caste system is not a stratification, but rather a unique type of inequality based on ritual and cultural ascription.
He sees purity and pollution manifesting in three phases: 1. The division of labour and occupational segregation based on purity/pollution. Eg Brahmins seen as clean, associated with God's worship. 2. The superiority of Brahmins — he remarks that the entire hierarchy is developed in reference to the Brahmins at the top, and the rest see their position that way. 3. The separation between the two — the polar opposition between pure aspects like vegetarianism and being clean, avoiding alcohol etc, and polluted aspects like non-veg, uncleanliness, alcohol use etc, is visible.
Many scholars have critiqued these notions. - Andre Beteille argues that this is what caste ought to be, but is far away from what it is. - Dumont has been called the 'Modern Manu' for reinforcing the binary of ritual separation as the basis of caste. - But today caste has proliferated and engages with class, power etc; these dimensions have been left out. - GD Berreman, in his study of Himalayan foothill people, says that they don't necessarily see themselves as polluted.
Castes have been reinventing their identities and using them, and the pollution-purity binary is not rigidly enforced.