Whether phenomenology represents a radical departure from the scientific method.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Phenomenology, formulated by thinkers like Alfred Schutz and Peter Berger strikes at the fundamental assumptions of the scientific method, and thus represents a "radical departure".
1. The scientific method presumes the externality of social fact, while phenomenology stresses internal process and interpretation. 2. The scientific method takes for granted the stability of meanings of various terms. However, Alfred Schutz argues that all definitions involve arbitrary classification of information, making them inherently subjective. 3. The scientific method relies on collection of statistical data. However, Atkinson and Cicourel have argued that there is no objective data, and all data reflects the subjective interpretation, for instance, suicide rates reflect views of police, coroners and judges on suicide. 4. The scientific method seeks to formulate generalized laws about society. Phenomenology discredits this approach since it militates against the idea of a discernible, objective truth. Rather, phenomenologists advocate studying the subjective meanings given by individuals to their social world.
Hence, phenomenology attacks at both the basis, methodology and even the aims of the scientific method.