The feminist critique of the family, marriage and kinship as traditionally defined.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Judith Butler's theory of Performativity of Gender in her book Gender Trouble mirrors the idea that "one is not born a woman, but becomes one". Feminist sociologists have long argued against traditional, "expressive", "domestic" roles attributed to women within kinship systems. They argue that such roles restrict the autonomy of women, and arise out of society, not biology.
Feminist challenge to Kinship 1. G.P. Murdock had defined the family as the sexual union of two adults of opposite sexes, raising children. Kathleen Gough in her study of the Nayars critiqued this patrilineal, patrilocal definition of kinship. 2. Scholars like M.S. Gore had pointed out that the joint family ideal type is patriarchal, patrilineal and coparcenary. Irawati Karve critiqued this unidimensional understanding by highlighting kinship systems of South, which may be matrilineal, and East, which may be matriarchal.
Feminist challenge to marriage 3. Functional theorists like Parsons had posited that the gender-based division of labour of men in "instrumental" bread-winner roles and women in "affective" care-oriented roles was efficient, natural and functional. Ann Oakley critiqued this understanding, stating that the housewife-carer role allocated to women was dysfunctional since it impeded their autonomy and led to the subjugation of women. 4. Marxist feminists point out that the exploitation of women within the family is to the benefit of the bourgeoisie. This is because unpaid care work done by women leads to raising new workers and providing emotional stability to existing workers. 5. Hoschilde has pointed out the persistent exploitation of women owing to gender roles even when both partners are working in her concept of The Second Shift. Here, she noted that despite working similar hours as the male counterpart, a women spends 30-70% more time on household chores. 6. Patriarchy as systemic subjugation: Sylvia Walby in "Theorizing Patriarchy" has pointed out the dual exploitation of women: - at the workplace, women are clustered in under-paying jobs in informal industries. - within the household, women are saddled with unpaid and undervalued care work and emotional labour.
Thus, it is not the biological attributes, but the social construction of gender that restricts women by imposing a narrow gender identity on them. It divests them of resources and entitlements, and perpetuates their dependence on men.