Examine Land Tenure system under British Rule. Do you think it was responsible for high inequality?
Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023
The land tenure system under British rule consisted of 3 systems: 1. Permanent Settlement (50% land under it) 2. Ryotwari Settlement (35% land) 3. Mahalwari Settlement (15% land)
[a pie chart labelled "Fig 1:- Distribution of Land under Land Tenure System" showing Mahalwari 15%, Permanent 50%, Ryotwari 35%]
Permanent Settlement In Bengal, Bihar - Under it, the zamindar got the ownership of the land and the peasant became the tenant. - The zamindar was supposed to pay 10/11 of rent to East India Company and keep the rest 1/11 with himself. - Under it, rent was fixed. Hence, it ensured stability of income to British.
Pros of Permanent Settlement - Stability of income to British - Administrative convenience - Zamindars became loyal political allies of British and helped them to suppress peasant revolts.
Cons of Permanent Settlement For the peasant: - Peasants could be evicted anytime at will - Absentee landlords emerged - Sub-letting of land occurred - High revenue extracted from peasants - Indebtedness increased.
For the zamindar: - Rents demanded were very high - There was a Sunset clause or deadline before which rent had to be paid, failing which the zamindar's land would be confiscated. - This led to benami transactions and manipulation of auctions to prevent British from confiscating zamindars lands
For the British: - In this system, the British could not raise the rent. - Thus, British income decreased as no. of zamindars increased in this system. - It also led to a lot of agrarian revolts.
Ryotwari Settlement In Madras. - Here, the British collected rent directly from the ryot.
Pros: Zamindars were eliminated.
Cons: Rent was very high (35-40%) and had to be paid despite droughts or plagues.
Mahalwari System In Punjab - Here, the rent was collected from a village via the village headman, also called Lambardar.
Cons: - Rents were very high - Productivity of land did not increase.
Thus, the land tenure systems exploited the Indian peasantry and the revenue collected was used to pay Home Charges by the British.