"Modernization does not necessarily lead to development." Analyze.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Modernization refers to the transition of a traditional, feudal, agrarian and rural society driven by religion to a capitalistic, industrial, urban, secularized society.
Modernization theorists like Rostow argued that underdevelopment of Global South was due to internal attributes like fatalism, feudal order, lack of work ethic, large families preventing savings etc. Rostow promoted the airoplane take off model whereby integration with global markets, foreign aid and technology transfers would lead to development.
"Modernization" does not lead to development Dependency theorists from Latin America argued that the cause of underdevelopment of Global South lay in its colonization and neocolonial exploitation by the Global North.
A.G. Frank argued against the modernization thesis, stating that the notion of modernization involves economic integration into a global capitalistic system. This would lead to the Global North ("core states") practising neocolonialism and exploiting the Global South (peripheral states).
Hence, even Wallerstein argued that capitalist modernization framework would further underdevelopment since it would embed the underdeveloped countries in an exploitative world system.