(b) Make a distinction between intragenerational and intergenerational social mobility. Why social mobility studies not adequately accounted for the position of women. Comment
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
According to Pitirim Sorokin, Social Mobility is the transition of an individual or group from one social position to the other.
| IntraGenerational | InterGenerational | |---|---| | Mobility of an individual or group within the same generation. | Mobility of an individual or group across two or three generations. | | Downward mobility of a person as a victim of natural disaster due to destruction of house is an Eg. | Upward mobility of the son of a farmer who works hard & gets educated & a job in corporate sector shows inter-generational mobility. | | Due to sudden & immediate changes like lottery, a poor beggar can become rich. | Long term changes might be required and continued efforts may take time to manifest. |
Social mobility studies have tried to study impact of several changes. Eg - Lipset hypothesis of how Industrialisation promoted social mobility. - Education as a source/growth enabler can cause social mobility specially in achievement oriented society. - Economic mobility - bourgeoisation thesis due to savings, welfare state and thrift values.
These studies did not adequately account for mobility among women. This contestation by feminist scholars like Ann Oakley is true as they argue that women continue to be oppressed irrespective or geographical or temporal considerations.
- These studies fail to recognise that the public sphere continues to be dominated by men, hence workplace study is only Half the Reality. - Patriarchal mindset, household division of labour continues to relegate women as second class citizens. - Rather "Feminisation of Poverty" is occurring due to male urban migration, lack of property control by women, <5% women as Board members in corporates: pink collarisation sustains subordinate status of women.