(a) Critically examine to what extent secularization in the modern society is a contested term.
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Secularization is seen as the reduced importance of religious beliefs, practices and norms in the day to day life of a human and in society.
Various manifestations have been observed:-
- Reduced church attendance in modern societies and services is seen as a parameter of secularisation. - Urbanisation has prevented values like Caste based discrimination difficult to observe Eg persons travelling in buses/trains, eating in restaurants etc. - Individualism has promoted secularization as more emphasis on personal freedom, choice rather than what religion prescribes. - 19 countries have legalised gay marriages & people are choosing own partners, live in relations no longer a taboo in urban India. - Modern technology of abortion, IVF technology, surrogacy etc are breaking barriers & beliefs of religious doctrines or rituals of sacrifice to cure babies or have them. - Industrial production & Modernisation is also fuelling secularization as modern education has nearly replaced religious textual reading at homes. Values of Universalism and Democracy are thus spreading. - Socialisation function is taken over by technology (ipads, AI toys etc) hence the Parents, Grandparents' role and consequent Intergenerational transfer of mythological religious stories is diminishing.
But this has been contested by several scholars:-
- Invisible Religion by Thomas Luckman states that religion is privatised & people stress on baptising kids, attending Sunday schools or home based practices. - Civil Religion by Robert Bellah argues for new basis of allegiance in national festivals, heroes, evoking similar ethos of dedication. - Elections in India reflect that Religion-Caste matrix plays huge role in candidate selection, victory, conferences etc even today. - Fundamentalism & Revivalism due to indoctrination, taliban & jihad are such. - New Religious Movement of Sects & Cults Eg like Mahesh Yogi's movement, ISKON, Art of living, Neo pentacostalism are instances of continued existence.
Hence secularisation thesis is much contested in contemporary society.