(b) "Durkheim was not the first thinker to attempt to make sociology a science." Critically examine
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Emile Durkheim is regarded as the torchbearer of the discipline of sociology in that he played crucial role to establish it as a separate field of study.
Durkheim stuck to Positivist understanding of society by studying social facts as independent, external entities that influence man's behaviour to be studied objectively without value interference. He elaborated in 'Rules of Sociological Method', how scientific method can be used to study society. He continued to illustrate this by using Indirect Experimentation on Arunta tribes for study of primitive religion; as also used Multivariate analysis and Concomitant Observation for study of Suicide. In this he proved how seemingly psychological phenomenon can be studied sociologically using appropriate methods.
But these attempts of Durkheim were not very radical or innovative, in sense that they followed same line of thought put forward by giants like August Comte. He first called the discipline 'Social Physics' before naming it sociology. Comte considered Sociology as the last of all sciences to be discovered and the king of all.
He stressed on positivist method by historical, comparative etc to study society using methods of natural sciences and to devise laws of human behaviour. Apart from Comte, Darwin's theory of Evolution and Herbert Spencer's organismic analogy of society laid the foundation of Sociology as science and functionalist doctrine.
This approach is criticised by Interpretivists who claim that man acts based on meanings he attaches to objective world, hence subjective understanding is important. Qualitative methods like unstructured interviews, Participant observation, conversational analysis and ethnomethodological approaches must supplement understanding of society.