Objectivity as a sociological goal
Srushti Deshmukh, AIR 5, 2018
Objectivity means conclusions arrives at by inquiry be independent of creed, race, colour, religion, moral preference & political disposition of the investigator - [Robert Bierstedt]
As a sociological goal, objectivity ensures that scientific method are adopted and observations of facts is free from prejudices and value bias
But its attainment in Sociology is disputed on following grounds:-
Objectivity is unachievable - 1. Choice of topic - is influenced by value relevance. Eg suicide as topic is unduly given attention. 2. Collection of facts - is contrained, as "lab" conditions cannot be simulated, response bias, hawthorne effect. Eg Andre Beteille was not allowed to visit dalit homes. 3. Interpretation - is coloured by the perspective/methodolgy. Eg Oscar Lewis and Robert Redfield studied same Mexican village but gave different interpretation 4. Theory building also not reliable Eg Religion seen as functional by Durkheim but as 'opium' by Marx
Objectivity not Desirable - 1. William Dilthey argues that quest for Objectivity/facts is only 1 Dimension ignores cultural/ideological angles 2. Gunnar Myrdal - reformist agenda is taken away 3. Weber - there cannot be an objective science of society as human action is rooted in meanings that man attaches.
Hence objectivity be attained by heuristic device like Verstehen, Ideal types etc for causal explanations which is disputed by Non-positivist school of thought who are more concerned with understanding than objectivity