Topper Copies

Explain Ratio Controversy.

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Ratio controversy is a controversy regarding the correct rupee-sterling exchange rate.

The Hilton Young Commission in 1926 recommended to overvalue the rupee from 1s 4d (1 sterling, 4 pence) to 1s 6d. This was opposed by the Indian nationalists, which led to the controversy.

CASE FOR 1s 6d:- - Young Commission argued that 1s 6d is the "de-facto" natural prevailing rate. - A devalued rupee would increase the burden of home charge obligations (fixed in sterling). Thus, appreciation of rupee is important. - Appreciation would also make British exports cheaper in India and benefit Lancashire mills

CASE FOR 1s 4d:- - Purushottam Dam Thakurdas argued that 1s 4d was the natural rate as it had been prevailing since 20 years. - Appreciation of rupee would harm agricultural and industrial exports from India. - Thus, Indian exports would suffer at the expense of foreign exports. - Appreciation of rupee would have a deflationary effect, which would discourage production by Indian Industries and make it difficult for the economy to recover from Great Economic depression of 1930s. - Devaluation would increase home charges burden. But it would also result in increase in trade and GDP which would compensate the Home charge burden. - Thus, Indian nationalists argued in favour of devaluation of rupee.