Durkheim's evolutionary theory of the division of labour, mechanical and organic solidarity, and its critics.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Durkheim studied division of labour from an evolutionary perspective, and its changing role, effect and essence across different societies on a temporal scale.
Durkheim's theory on division of labour (DoL)
1. Functionalist in nature - Durkheim's idea on DoL proposes its role in developing collective conscience and social solidarity. 2. Types of DoL - Durkheim underlines two types: - Mechanical solidarity - solidarity of homogeneity, characteristic of primitive societies, where the nature of the job of individuals was homogeneous. - Organic solidarity - characteristic of modern, capitalist society, marked by growing interdependence of individuals due to differentiation and heterogeneity. 3. Division of labour as a basis of social change - Durkheim's idea highlights DoL's utility in adapting and social solidarity, with social change where capitalism, marked by differentiation and specialisation, leads to social integration of DoL. 4. Ideas on forced division of labour, leading to 'anomie', where a social group forces upon another, leading to excessive social regulation and anomie. The solution proposed is the development of 'corporates' in complex industrial spaces, to prevent suicides and anomic behaviour.
But the theory has been widely criticized:
- Lockwood - Durkheim misinterprets social dependence with social integration. - CW Mills - does not take into account the power and domination of capitalists that influence division of labour. - Malinowski - division of labour as a basis of social change is flawed. - Feminists like Dorothy Smith criticised it for justifying marginalisation and gender stereotypes. - Gramsci - division of labour is divisive in nature, instead of enacting solidarity.
Hence, Durkheim's idea of division of labour was pioneering in understanding the phenomenon in sociology.