Mead's concept of self, the 'I' and the 'Me', and its critics.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
Mead, in his 'Mind, Self and Society', provides a pioneering work on social psychology, understanding the growth of self from society's point of view.
Mead defines self as a peculiar ability to be both subject and object, that forms through social interactions. To further enrich this, he gives the concept of 'I' and 'Me' as forms of self:
| 'I' | 'Me' | |---|---| | Immediate response to others | Adoption of 'generalised others' - social self | | Promotes social change | Status quoist | | Storehouse of novelty and creativity | Promotes conformity | | We are never fully aware of 'I' | Completely aware | | Modern society feature | (Traditional) primitive society prevalent |
This conception of 'I' and 'Me' has been criticized:
1. Ritzer founds it faulty to consider 'self as independent' (I) to be modern, whereas 'self as part of society' (Me) be traditional. 2. McCall and Simmons - Mead is obsessed with the superiority of 'I', a eurocentric view. 3. Erikson - Mead's idea is narrowed, and provided an extension by the 8-stage development of self. 4. Ropes - excessive social determinism.
Hence, Jean Dewey's saying that Mead is 'the seminal mind of first order' is apt.