Topper Copies

Marshall's theory of citizenship and its three kinds of rights.

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Citizenship refers to the dual nature of relation and interaction of individuals with a state, in the form of rights and duties.

Emphasising on rights, Marshall's theory of citizenship focuses on three kinds of rights:

1. Civil rights - rights for the individual to obtain rights in the civic sphere: freedom to form associations, speech, movement etc. 2. Political rights - rights to form political associations, fight elections, vote and hold public offices. 3. Social rights - aspire to raise one's social standards and strive for equality. Ex rights against discrimination, exclusion.

Citizenship is in conflict with capitalistic views, as Marshall believes the latter is about discriminatory forces, but citizenship promotes egalitarian views and sees the individual on an equal pedestal.

But his ideology has been criticized:

- Failure in providing rights - Marxists and neo-Marxists highlight citizenship's shortfall in true realisation of rights (Westergaard and Resler). - Extension of capitalism - in a liberal economy, where domestic bourgeoisie prevents goods and business from foreign entry. - Less emphasis on duties and moral obligation by citizens.

Hence, with the emergence of 'global citizenship', Marshall's idea of citizenship, although relevant, demands amendments.