A certain State government was running a welfare scheme for promoting safe motherhood among rural landless laborers' families. The scheme involves the transfer of funds to the beneficiaries to enable them to mitigate income loss due to maternal care responsibilities. Since its implementation, the scheme has done reasonably well on maternal health and economic indicators. You are the Director of the Department responsible for implementing and operating the scheme. Recently you have been receiving reports of welfare fraud being committed by families by producing fake bona fide. The families committed the fraud with the help of local officials responsible for scrutinizing the bonafide. You were concerned because the fraud was seriously undermining the scheme's efficiency. You called for a departmental meeting to discuss and find a solution to the problem. In the meeting, it was decided to merge several available government data sets such as Aadhar cards, voter ID cards, marriage certificates, birth certificates, bank details, and other personal assets. By merging all the data sets, the department would be able to develop the beneficiary's economic profile. And this will help the department scrutinize the documents and detect fraud. This was a comprehensive strategy, but it risked violating an individual's data privacy. As a Department head, you wanted to detect and prevent fraud, but at the same time, you were apprehensive about violating the Data privacy of the stakeholders. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) Do you think violating data privacy is justified to prevent welfare fraud? Why/ Why not? (c) What, according to you, can be the reasons for such welfare frauds happening in the country? (d) Are there any ways and means to prevent such fraud? Give your suggestions. (Answer in 250 words)
Vishnu Sasikumar, AIR 31, 2023
The case study shows the large scale problem of leakage in govt welfare programmes due to ethical bankruptcy among people. This is leading to denial of rights to many eligible beneficiaries due to inefficient utilisation of resource.
(a) Issues involved in the case
1. Ethical erosion among beneficiaries as they are misusing a good scheme. 2. Corruption among public official as they are colluding with local people. 3. Issue of possible breach of privacy which is a constitutional moral as per Puttuswamy Judgement. 4. Poor regulation and implementation of the scheme.
(b) Is violating data privacy justified
Violation of data privacy would be justified looking from Utilitarian perspective as it leads to Greatest Happiness for Greatest Number. By violating privacy if govt is able to rationalise the scheme, it would bring in better resource use ensuring welfare reaches to all without any leakage. Computerisation would also lead to increased transparency and accountability as govt has records to show to the people.
However, the Kantian categorical Imperativism suggests its highly unethical as the action itself is immoral. The code of dark web and data being sold reduces the ethicality of action
At the end of the day, if the welfare is to be increased, breach of privacy by integrating all data sets must be done. Govt can complement it with Data Protection Act to ensure privacy & welfare
(c) Reasons for welfare fraud
Given India's commitment of being a welfare state, there are a host of welfare schemes. However different issues lead to welfare fraud. They are:
1. Culture of corruption among people as people believe corrupt ways can lead to ineligible achievements. 2. Corruption nexus and collusion between the govt officials & people. 3. Reduced integrity and respect for laws among citizenry. 4. Lack of proper regulatory and auditing mechanisms to oversee the schemes. 5. Rising cost & inflation push people to welfare fraud to ensure good standard of living. 6. Lack of deterrence by punishment.
(d) Ways to remove such fraud
1. Imbibe integrity by rewarding integrity through integrity models (Nepal) or Honest stores (Kerala). 2. Conducting regular audits of the schemes by CAG or Social Audits (Meghalaya, Mizoram). 3. Digitisation of the schemes to reduce bureaucratesation & discretion 4. Effective punishment for those who do welfare fraud by giving jail terms. 5. Increasing people's well being & standard of living through development to reduce dependence on welfare schemes.
Effective digitisation and ethical literacy among people would ensure that welfare frauds are reduced, ensuring the benefits reach to last mile standing, leading to Antyodaya.